.
Feedback

Betrayal - A Soldier's Perspective

Imagine a full year of your life devoted to accomplishing a single goal, and seeing others make the supreme sacrifice to do so. Imagine seeing that mission betrayed by the very people who you saved.

 

This perspective offered for any who have ever discussed our Country's involvement in overseas conflicts AND wants true insight into whatever debate there may have been or is yet to come. This is not from a politician, bureaucrat, or activist; it is personal and from my son Chris, a combat veteran who commanded troops and was directly involved.

I am confident that you will learn more about our military involvement from this one passage than from all the hot air, bluster, bravado, and commentary you have heard to date. While this one "Soldier's Story" is most personal for Chris and our family, he agreed that it was one that needed to be told.

Then a 1st Lieutenant and platoon leader, Chris' 4th Brigade Combat Team, 82nd Airborne deployed in the summer of 2009 to Farah Province in Afghanistan. Farah was one of the most insecure areas in the relatively peaceful west, and Chris and the men of "C" Troop, 4-73 Cavalry, were assigned the unenviable and difficult task of clearing out the Taliban from a place that no one ever imagined them leaving.

Their assault on the provincial city of Shewan broke the back of the Taliban, and brought much needed medical help and supplies to a beleaguered populace. Over that year of deployment, these brave soldiers stabilized the region, losing forty of their own doing so. A successful mission by any measure.

When Chris and his comrades fought in this operation in Shewan, our family lived through it stateside, hoping for both a successful mission and his safe return. With God's help, we realized both.

Yesterday, we learned the unthinkable; the BBC reported an Afghan police commander and 13 junior officers joined the Taliban in the western Afghan province of Farah, in what correspondents say could be the biggest defection by police. The men are said to have taken heavy weaponry, radios and police vehicles including US-made armored Humvees.

"Long before the commander defected, he must have been passing intelligence and crucial information to the insurgents," an official stated.  The province has a strategic position, bordering Iran, and the key Kandahar-Herat highway passes through Farah, which is now seeing increasing levels of violence.

I can only imagine the pain, the sense of betrayal, those who served in this operation felt. Chris offered the following perspective which begins to detail that “Soldier's Story":  

"For my civilian friends: To put how this feels into perspective for you, imagine taking an entire year of your life, and devoting it to accomplishing a single goal. Imagine you and the best people you know pouring their blood, sweat, and tears into a cause. Picture endless dismounted patrols in the hot sun, in sandstorms, dust, mud, with 75 to 120 pounds of equipment, often three times a day on less than five hours sleep. Envision spending countless hours training and equipping a people to fight their aggressors, and standing side-by-side with them in doing so.

Now, picture that after all of that work, and all of the broken hearts and broken families that resulted from it, you wake up one day and discover that the goal you were working towards has been crushed. Now, you might be able to understand the impact of this article on anyone from C Troop, 4-73 Cavalry, and the men who fought before, after, and alongside us.

For my former Soldiers: Despite how this might feel for you (and it might feel completely different for each one of you), it does not minimize what we did together. We cleared the Taliban from a place that no one ever imagined them leaving, even if only for a time. We demonstrated that men from diverse backgrounds working together can overcome the most austere and dangerous conditions.

We left it all on the field, and we have nothing to be ashamed of. When we are all grandparents, we can still proudly speak of the sacrifice that was put into a noble cause, and of the fight we took to the enemy in the name of freedom and in response to the worst attack on our nation in its history."

This is real, true, and should make each and every one of us demand politicians clearly define the implementation and expectation of our mission before we commit the lives of our real 1% ... the heroic men and women of our Armed Forces. We should not expect these warriors to accomplish a mission, spilling their blood to do that, only to see those sacrifices betrayed. All that said as a proud yet somewhat frustrated military Dad, I am most proud of the fact that I know each and every one of Chris' comrades feel the same way he does, and will hold their head high with the knowledge that yes, they answered the bell when their nation called. We are all blessed to have them and all those who served before them.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from New City Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Kathleen May 21, 2013 at 08:55 am
CANDLE Night at the Rockland Boulders Game Join CANDLE for a fun(d)raising game on May 23rd as theRead More Rockland Boulders take on the Trois-Rivieres Aigles. Proceeds from tickets purchased through CANDLE* will support programs that educate & empower youth and reduce substance abuse and violence in Rockland County and beyond.
Heywood Jablohme May 21, 2013 at 02:48 pm
I agree with most of your points, but surely you are not implying that teachers are expected toRead More produce funding to correct school roofs, right? I think you got a bit off topic here, but I agree that our educational infrastructure is in disrepair and is in desperate need of rehabilitation. Maybe if our teacher's unions allowed a little more leeway we could allocate funding a little more appropriately and fund the important things instead of overpaying paying dinosaur teachers who lost interest a long time ago and fight any and all forms of teacher benchmarking.
WGMom May 20, 2013 at 09:10 am
It's entirely true that every professional has out-of-pocket expenses. But as someone who worked asRead More a corporate trainer, I can guarantee you I NEVER had to pay out of pocket expenses for supplies to teach classes. Every piece of paper, supply, and even snacks for the participants were fully covered expenses. If I had to spend out of pocket money to procure supplies, I could submit for a reimbursement, and receive it, no questions asked. I am now in school to become a high school teacher and I can see the stark difference in how the education of folks in a corporate environment is incredibly different, and privileged, than the public school environment. I've sat through numerous classes in the Clarkstown and Ramapo districts, doing observations required for my education certification, and while Clarkstown certainly benefits from certain advantages, the shabbiness of being a public school is still there. Furniture, such as teacher desks, that looks like it was purchased in a garage sale 30 years ago... faculty bathrooms that are dark and dingy, nearly crumbling, and sorely in need of updating. Etc. The public expects teachers to have professional training, act professionally, but they lack sometimes basic resources and are expected to function in an environment that feels more like a dungeon than an institution of learning. The citizens of Clarkstown, if they could get a tour of some of the facilities they are expecting children to learn in, and teachers to teach in, would be very surprised. We do supply some great technology, but then we put it in classrooms with windows that won't stay closed when it's windy, as one example. I spent most of my time in South, which is the best of the bunch, facilities-wise. Clarkstown North is a mess, Woodglen's woods are littered with fallen trees no one's cleaned up after Sandy, Laurel Plains had to be shuttered thanks to that whole foul stench... the district is in a situation where there are major capital improvements that are going to be needed. Buildings are aging, and it seems it's only the most basic of upkeep that happens. The district can't even fix the roofs of the buildings without applying for a state grant.
Heywood Jablohme May 18, 2013 at 07:17 am
What professional doesn't spend $500 per year on out of pocket expenses related to their jobs?Read More Staples offering 10% (or 5 in some cases) is hardly an example of the community getting involved. Thankfully, there are other examples of the community and PTA's getting involved and providing needed services. Clarkstown and surrounding areas hardly have substantial unmet needs in their classroom, thankfully.
Truth4all May 16, 2013 at 11:37 am
I guess better late than never. LaCorte is serving his 4th year as Mayor and was Trustee for I thinkRead More 4 years before that. This year is the only time he has brought the idea to the village about participating in this program. He is motivated by the opportunity of getting positive press for his County Executive campaign. The village should have been involved in this program ( as well as the Americorps program) long before this. On a positive note, hopefully the Village will continue this worthwhile partnership for many years to come.
Sunny May 16, 2013 at 03:50 pm
Is there an article on patch about it? I am unable to find except on lohud.com
Green Farmer May 15, 2013 at 08:23 pm
Finally!!
b May 15, 2013 at 07:31 pm
Thank God. It's been a long time coming. Finally someone has paid attention.!!! That man has gotRead More to go.
Watchdog May 16, 2013 at 04:37 pm
George, don't you have enough to do straightening out the affairs of Clarkstown. Overtime in theRead More Police Department is rampant and the Town Attorney is out of control. As Tom Nimick says, we need an outside auditor for that operation since taxpayers were abused with the hiring of a political operative Jay Savino who I understand is singing like a canary. Get on the right side George before the FBI comes a lookin" I hear that the Gromack war chest is the first place they are looking for clues. Do the right thing George or you will get trampled with the rest of them.
Tom Nimick May 15, 2013 at 11:12 pm
Congratulations, George. Now about your other responsibilities as a member of the Town Board withRead More primary oversight over budget and expenditures: Won't you be the one to propose the needed audit of the Office of Town Attorney? You know the problems exist - likely you know more about the problems than I do. It is sad to see you silent in the face of the abuse of patronage. When will we hear your voice on it?
Teacher May 16, 2013 at 07:24 am
The new format is attractive but it is hard to find the comments that go with stories.