New Head Of Rockland Independence Party Indicted On Perjury Charges

Debra Ortutay of Valley Cottage accused of falsely testifying in civil lawsuit over election petition signatures.

The Valley Cottage woman who became head of the Independence Party in Rockland County after a fight for control of the group in 2010 has been arrested on a 17-count indictment charging her with perjury in connection with her testimony in court about the gathering of election petition signatures.

Westchester County District Attorney Janet DiFiore said Debra Ortutay, 56, of 15 Forest Glen Road, Valley Cottage, was arraigned in New City today, after the unsealing of an indictment handed down by a Rockland County grand jury.

DiFiore’s office was named special prosecutor for the investigation of Ortutay following a request by the Rockland County District Attorney’s Office to be disqualified from the investigation. Ortutay is mother-in-law of Rockland County Legislator Frank Sparaco, R-Valley Cottage.

Ortutay is accused of:

  • One count of Perjury in the First Degree, a class “D” Felony,
  • Ten counts of Criminal Possession of a Forged Instrument in the Second  Degree, class “D” Felonies,
  • Two counts of Offering a False Instrument for Filing in the First Degree, class “E” Felonies,
  • Two counts of Making a Punishable False Written Statement, class “A” Misdemeanors,
  • Two count of Misdemeanors at, or in Connection with, Primary Elections, Caucuses, Enrollment in Political Parties, Committees, and Conventions, in violation of New York State Election law, a class “A” Misdemeanor,
  • Two count of Misconduct in Relation to Petitions, in violation of New York State Election Law, a class “A” Misdemeanor.

The grand jury voted the indictment on June 22.

“Our electoral process does not work unless voters have absolute trust in the integrity of the system,” said DiFiore. “The allegations contained in the indictment, that the defendant tampered with the most basic aspect of the electoral process, the collection of petition signatures, disenfranchised the voters of Rockland County. And then, by lying about her actions in a court proceeding challenging those signatures, only served to further erode that public trust."

In November 2010, Ortutay was elected as a state committee member of the Rockland County Independence Party in a campaign to oust the former leadership of the party, of which Marsha Coopersmith was chairman. In December 2010, Ortutay was elected chairwoman of the group.

DiFiore said that as chairwoman, Ortutay is the highest Independence Party office holder in Rockland County and is responsible for coordinating the party’s activities in the county, including screening candidates for office and determining which candidates will receive the party’s endorsement.

DiFiore said that between July 20 and Aug. 6, 2010, Ortutay attested to the validity of signatures on Opportunity to Ballot petitions from the 94th Assembly District in Rockland County. DiFiore said that Ortutay, knowing that she had not witnessed those signatures, testified in a civil proceeding that challenged the validity of those same signatures before state Supreme Court Justice William Giacomo in August 2010, where she lied about her actions.

Assemblyman Kenneth Zebrowski, D-New City, won re-election in the 94th District last November. Sparaco ran against Zebrowski for the seat and waged a primary with Zebrwoski for the Indepence Party line in the election — with Zebrwoski winning 198 to 172.

Ortutay was released pending a July 19 hearing in Rockland County Court. If convicted, Ortutay faces a maximum of two and one half to seven years in prison.

The Independence Party is one of several so-called third party groups in Rockland County that appear on local ballots. While Democrats have an overwhelming majority among registered voters in Rockland County with nearly 182,000 members, parties such as the Independence Party look to attract the more than 41,000 voters in Rockland County who leave their party affiliation blank.

johnnyangel10 July 01, 2011 at 06:38 PM
It's a shame that anyone would get so involved with an Independent Party in the first place. What is an independent party? Is that where you have the mind of an independent person? You have two parties in this country as 'swing voters',they are not too convinced of either sides politics.They do not have a definite ideal of what their politics are,I personally don't understand an independent unless it makes them have a certain feeling about who sounds better at the time.All that I will say is no political party is worth getting in trouble over,but independents? No,I don't get that one at all!I will say a prayer for her and probably it is best if she stays out of politics and not take it too seriously,after all look who is in the White House now.
George C July 02, 2011 at 02:41 AM
Why have 3rd parties at all if all they do in cross endorse candidates as opposed to running their own. They exist solely to gain favors, jobs, and influence. Take a look at who controls both the conservative and independence parties in Clarkstown. They all have nice high paying jobs with the town.
Edward Branca July 03, 2011 at 01:32 PM
Of course Ortutay is innocent until the jury finds her guilty. But we always read headlines in the paper or on-line. The headlines contain the name of a politician and one of the following words, "indicted," "convicted" or "sentanced."
Tony T July 03, 2011 at 01:39 PM
We should be more vigilient in rooting out election fraud....especially with our illegal immigrant population!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »