Nyack Residents React To Arson Arrest

Some residents feel that although an arrest has been made, other issues within the neighborhood still need to be addressed, such as squatters and drunken strangers.

Nyack residents are still shaken from the recent arson incidents. 

A 16-year-old Nyack boy was  on arson charges stemming from  set in Nyack early Tuesday on Summit Street and Washington Street in Nyack and a separate fire over the weekend, Orangetown police said Thursday morning.

Investigation efforts  that unlocked a series of connections, which led to Wednesday's arrest of Jonathan Barillas. Although he's now behind bars, residents on Summit Street have mixed feelings. 

Fernando and Rosa Hudson are just a few houses down from their neighbors whose cars were set on fire.

“The night it happened, it was scary because there were all these popping sounds (from the fire). It was probably pockets of oil burning and exploding in the car,” said Fernando Hudson, adding that he and his wife thought that the popping noise was gunshots at first.

He said that he had a hunch that it may have been caused by an adolescent because he said there's been times in the past where small rocks were thrown at his home by a group of teens or that same group would be roughhousing around the neighborhood.

"I also could tell they were young because older people can't run like that. When this happened, I was hoping it wasn't those young children getting into more dangerous things," he said. "I felt more irritation than real anger. I don't feel safer or less safe. This is a fine neighborhood and I feel sorry for the young kid that was caught doing it. At least it was just juvenile madness and not a concerted effort.”

Barillas is also charged with stealing items from unlocked cars throughout the Summit Street neighborhood the same morning as the fires. Hudson added that they “were lucky” because their car was not locked that night.  

“Our car has been broken into by vagrants, again not a concerted effort to do evil things, just lost souls,” he said.

Several doors down, another Summit Street resident also said he thought the popping sounds were shots being fired too.

“I thought it was a gun,” said Fred Garmone. Garmone’s neighbors at 35 Summit St. had to evacaute their home because the car fire spread to the side of their house.

Garmone said that the resident opposite of 35 Summit St. was awake and noticed the fire through her window.

“She came out yelling,” said Garmone. “Our window was open so we heard her and we came out of the house too.”

“Thank God she was up; she was up watching TV and saw the (car) fire,” said another neighbor, who chose not to be named. “She ran out onto the street yelling. We knew something was strange (and that it wasn't just a random accident) because before the firefighters came, the car door was open and burning.”

Garmone added that although many residents are happy that the police arrested Barillas, this is not the first nor will it be the last of issues that their neighborhood encounters.

“When I saw the news today, I was pretty relieved. (Before seeing the news of Barillas’ arrest), I was still thinking that he could be out there and could strike again,” said Garmone. “I think we feel better that the person is caught, but I think that everyone around here feels that … there are other issues on this street. We talked about having a neighborhood meeting with the mayor to talk about some of our issues. This has brought everything to the forefront, like minor things that’s been going on. We’ve had an issue with squatters … living in abandoned houses and drunk traffic and (indecent behavior from strangers).”

Another Summit Street resident suggested starting a neighborhood watch group.

Will McAvoy August 24, 2012 at 07:26 PM
There are liberals everywhere in Rockland.
concerned for the kids August 24, 2012 at 08:42 PM
its a shame this poor kid hasnt got anyone to keep him straight, or no place to go for all that, what else can these kids do? why dont they have a recreational game room or something in nyack, Ibet that would be a good thing thing for these kids, i feel sorry for these kids in any village, if these villages, not only nyack, can put this together and use some of your tax money to give them some place to go, they wouldnt have to hang out in your nieghborhood looking for things to do. and there parents will know where they are, theres plenty of empty storefronts in all these towns that could be turned into a recreational game room. palisades mall is the closest its far for a kid
anonymous August 25, 2012 at 09:30 PM
i'm his ex girlfriend, and i have to say that he does have some issues, hence the fact that i am his EX. he's been having trouble for the past few years. he does drugs and has been detained before. i feel very bad for what happened but at the same time, he deserves it. he did not listen to me when i tried to help him before, and i wish someone was around to help him now. though i think he still would've not listened. it just sucks. and i hope that this will finally set him straight.
K.Cobain August 26, 2012 at 02:09 PM
Nyack has many recreational places to go. You really think if Nyack had another game room this kid wouldn't be out at 230 in the morning setting cars, houses and a businesses on fire.. He needs parents who show him the difference between right and wrong for starters and some psychological evaluations..
K.Cobain August 26, 2012 at 02:11 PM
Lucky for us you don't come into Nyack any longer. You sound like nothing but a bitter person from reading your rants..So you did us Nyackers a favor and for that.. Thank you.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »