Carlucci Dashes Hope Of Sales Tax Increase To Ease Deficit

Senator announce he will not support local sales tax hike


Senator David Carlucci announced Monday he will not support the three-eighths of one percent sales tax increase proposed by county officials.

“After lengthy discussions with Rockland County officials, representatives from the Governor's office, the State Comptroller's office, and the Finance Committees in the both the Senate and Assembly, I have decided not to support the sales tax increase at this time because there is little evidence that it would solve ,” said Carlucci in a statement. 

County Legislator and Budget & Finance Committee Chairman Ilan Schoenberger said on Friday morning Carlucci said he would introduce the bill but by the afternoon had changed his mind. Schoenberger said Carlucci first called him at 8:15 a.m. and he said he was introducing the bill. But at 3:30 p.m. he called again and he was not going to introduce it.

“He didn’t give me any reason, he just said he was not introducing it,” said Schoenberger.

The county executive’s office had not been formally notified of the decision.

“To my knowledge, we don’t have a formal letter,” said Levine.

Carlucci’s spokesman, Jason Elan, said, “The whole concept behind the sales tax, we don’t think this is a long term sustainable strategy.” He noted that from Day One, Carlucci did not think the bill had a real chance of getting passed in the Senate.

Carlucci also stated, “I remain committed to working with Rockland County to help them find a way out of its financial mess, however at this time I can not in good faith submit a home rule request to increase taxes on the already over taxed residents of Rockland County.”

Schoenberger said a portion of the money raised by the sales tax hike was to be dedicated to paying for the 10-year deficit bond.  He noted that the money raised would be coming from everyone who shopped in Rockland, not just its residents. He questioned why Carlucci’s decision came almost three and a half months after the request was presented on January 19.

Ron Levine, spokesman for County Executive C. Scott Vanderhoef, noted the sales tax increase was presented by the legislature as one of the ways to reduce the $80 million deficit.  Vanderhoef had initially proposed laying off more than 500 county employees, which the legislators opposed. Vanderhoef decided not to veto the legislature’s measure.

In his remarks, Carlucci noted the county was seeking to raise taxes at a time when the state is working to reduce them.

“At the state level we have worked with the Governor to close a $13.5 billion dollar budget gap while cutting taxes to the lowest level in 50 years.  To support a sales tax increase at this time, with the economy still in recovery, would be a step backwards on progress we have made.” 

Carlucci referred to the pending financial review of the Summit Park Nursing Home as not being made public.  Levine said the final report has not been completed. Summit Park has been losing millions each of the past several years.

Carlucci pointed to several other issues that he said concerned him. One was the $18 million in planned union concessions that have not been agreed upon and the other was the drop in the county’s sales tax revenue for the first quarter. He said it fell nearly $500,000 for the first three months of 2012, which showed the riskiness of relying on it to help balance the budget.

State Assembly members Ellen Jaffee (95th District) and Annie Rabbitt (97th District) introduced the home rule legislation in the assembly.  

It is unclear what county government’s next step will be.

“It just means we’re just going to move forward and consider other options,” said Levine. “There’ll be a reaction, a commonsense reaction of what we have to do.”

Schoenberger predicted difficult financial times ahead for many Rockland residents because of the decision.

“He has abandoned the people of Rockland County,” he said. “There will probably be hundreds of people laid off.”

Michael N. Hull May 08, 2012 at 10:33 AM
No, Mr Schoenberger, it is you, and your fellow legislators that have been in the legislature for many years, who have abandoned the Town with reckless spending and self serving explanations. http://newcity.patch.com/blog_posts/rocklands-ride-to-fiscal-disaster You want some other county's taxpayers to pay for the spending mess you got Rockland County into.  Carlucci has simply told you to put your own house in order while the State, and other counties within the State, will have to do likewise. Stop the blame game!  It is not working any more.  We see the smoke and don't need to look in the mirrors. You created the deficit and the debt and sooner or later the pain will be great enough on the taxpayers that they may throw you out. By the way, how is Vanderhoef doing with 'keeping time'?   Has he come up with a Finance Director yet that can count your mythical beans? http://newcity.patch.com/blog_posts/we-havent-had-time
Scott Walters May 08, 2012 at 10:56 AM
It appears that Mr. Carlucci has actually decided to be an independent Democrat. Good for him on this one....
Scott Walters May 08, 2012 at 10:58 AM
And how long has Schoenberger been in office????And didn't see this coming....shame on him for not seeing it, and a bigger shame on th those who insist on voting him back in to do more damage. A pity party is in order here....LOL
Mary May 08, 2012 at 11:07 AM
Thank you Mr. Carlucci...someone is finally saying it out loud. When will people realize it's not a revenue problem...it's a spending problem.
Mike Hirsch May 08, 2012 at 11:39 AM
Thank you Michael. I couldn't have said it any better.
Mike Hirsch May 08, 2012 at 11:46 AM
There is a schism in the Democratic Party since Christain Zebrowski took charge. The youngsters (her brother, David, and Hausner take their marching orders from her, not from the old guard (Gromack, Cornell, and Schoenberger). It is very unusual for someone affiliated with a major party to be truly independent. The only one who even comes halfway close is Ed Day.
Mike Hirsch May 08, 2012 at 11:48 AM
I'm loving this stuff. Cornell and Schoenberger have finally run out of our money to spend, can't raise taxes, and can't even borrow against our homes by putting the county further in debt.
Mike Hirsch May 08, 2012 at 11:49 AM
Mary, please introduce yourself if we happen to cross paths.
ADK May 08, 2012 at 12:30 PM
Bravo David! a Politician with an independent mindset...its all we can ask of our representatives...
Mike Hirsch May 08, 2012 at 01:09 PM
ADK, I thought you were more intelligent than that. A political career precludes an independent mindset. A truly independent mindset in a successful career politician is very rare to behold. Teddy Roosevelt had an independent mindset, as does Ron Paul. No one in our county comes close. Ed Day is the only one who is halfway there.
Scott Walters May 08, 2012 at 01:14 PM
No FInance Director, but the Tourism lackey is still there...
Michael N. Hull May 08, 2012 at 01:54 PM
Mike:  You say to ADK "I thought you were more intelligent than that ......" I agree with ADK - Carlucci did what I thought he would do and what he did was the right thing.  Let us applaud the action.   In addition to Ed Day's independence I would add that of Cris Carey's.  We can applaud their actions  too. The same goes for Hausner's vote against Savino.  We can again applaud this action and hope that it shows independent thought, ethical behavior, and a promise of future good governance. Let's reserve comments about 'intelligence' for the Town Attorney, Amy Mele, who can't recall who brought Bronx Republican Party Head, Jay Savino, to her attention for a position in the Town at $87,000 per year or for Town Supervisor, Gromack, who said: "Maybe it was someone that was proactive from his firm that contacted the Town Attorney's office and said if there was ever an opportunity please give me a call ..... And that's probably the way it happened". http://newcity.patch.com/articles/questions-linger-about-clarkstown-s-hiring-of-firm-for-tax-cert-matters http://newcity.patch.com/articles/questions-and-still-more-questions http://newcity.patch.com/articles/questions-never-do-damage Where 'intelligence' is concerned and I hear 'can't recall', 'maybe', and 'probably' then my definition of low intelligence is:  'Stupid is as Stupid does'!
Smitty Chesterfield May 08, 2012 at 02:30 PM
Hey Vanderhoef, don't spill the milk and ask us to clean it up for you.
Michael Gries May 08, 2012 at 02:40 PM
Carlucci sees we are at or past the point of diminishing returns. The higher the tax - the more people go elsewhere. The county must cut spending.
Pat May 08, 2012 at 02:45 PM
This is a win-win for Carlucci, Vanderhoef, the RC legislature and the publicly funded union workers. Carlucci comes across as a fiscally conservative democrat, Vanderhoef can point at the failure to increase the sales tax as a victory because he "had reservations" when he played dead and signed the budget, all the while he and the RC legislature can still bank on the 30% property tax increase for this year. They both can up property tax again next year with a more modest increase because of the upcoming shortfall (I can hear it now, "only $45 per household, blah blah blah) and all the union members who gave up nothing, can once again play the "union busting and workers rights" song and dance at next years budget/contract debate. It's like a symphony "orchestra" how it all comes together. Rest assured that the band will play on.
Anthony Mele May 08, 2012 at 03:35 PM
It's a lose/lose ploy my Friends. Offering us an Umbrella in a Hurricane is not relief nor is giving a drowning victim a glass of water a remedy. It is not largesse to permit us to keep more of our own money. If they want our adulation return our money, cut spending, cut taxes, stop borrowing, let the free markets adjust accordingly. I for one, am disappointed at the playing of politics while we are in a real, true to life, fiscal crisis. I admire and respect everyone on this thread, as you all know me and I know you. David is doing what he is told in Albany by them not us. First he told Elan he would support it, then, someone else told him don't support it, so he announced he wouldn't. That is not decisiveness. That is following instructions. We are no better off, there is no solution offered, and they will find other ways to pick our pocket. The solution offered itself on election day. Don't blame a spender for spending or a borrower for borrowing. We need solutions now. Not political gamesmanship. Raise your hand if you think a politician letting you keep a penny in your pocket now, but takes ten dollars from you later is a win/win.
Scott Walters May 08, 2012 at 04:32 PM
And guess who has to pay the piper....???
George C May 08, 2012 at 05:50 PM
Excellent point. Between the town, county, and school taxes, all I see is more of my money going towards taxes and my paycheck getting smaller and smaller. Where are the spending cut proposals. The reduction of workforce, elimination of unnecessary services. We can't afford any more increases in taxes. I did not make this mess, yet I am left to pay for it.
Tired OF HIGH TAXES May 10, 2012 at 04:47 PM
Again and again the RC legislator always points the blame elsewhere! Its about time they are called on the Carpet and to be fiscally responsible with OUR hard earned money! Just look around at the for sale signs and foreclosures! They blame the Union! Thats a LIE The union workers work hard and have in some cases work 2 and 3 jobs to survive here and their pensions are below the poverty level, so blame them I think NOT! Its the administration and the Management who by the way have a special union and make a far greater salary and pension then the regular worker! Its time to cut the duplication of management jobs first and foremost! Time to vote these irresponsible people out of office!
Andrew Wiley May 15, 2012 at 03:09 AM
Thanks David for keeping your word.This tax will not solve our structural spending imbalances.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »