Legislators Vote In Favor Of Motor Vehicle Tax

Legislator acted on other resolutions this week


The Rockland County Legislature voted in favor of a new motor vehicle tax for residents at Tuesday’s meeting. The tax calls for car owners to pay $5 when registering a vehicle or $10 when registering an SUV or commercial vehicle more than 3,500 pounds.

The vote came Tuesday night after a brief public hearing on the tax where only two people spoke. The resolution passed on a 14-3 vote, with Legislators Frank Sparaco, Ed Day and Chris Carey voting against it. 

Both were against the tax and Jim Flynn, of Nanuet, said he’d prefer another property tax increase because he can deduct that later.

“Having different kinds of taxes like this where non-property owners also have to pay, where anyone who wants to register a vehicle has to pay, it’s good to spread it around to property owners and non-property owners, it really is, I think,” Legislator Joseph Meyers said. “I felt the same way about the home energy tax. It was much more preferable to me than the sales tax because, I think, when you raise your sales tax, people coming from outside the county don’t want to shop here. That’s not a good thing for our businesses, and people look at how much a sales tax is in counties.”

Meyers added that raising property taxes can also hurt homeowners when they look to sell, which is another reason he preferred to raise a different tax.

Legislator Ed Day offered an amendment to the bill to have it expire two years after it officially starts up. The amendment was denied.

“It’s way too premature. We don’t have our deficit bond yet, we’ve asked the state for it and hope we’re going to get it. We haven’t had our books closed yet for 2011, and we won’t be able to sell that BAN, bond anticipation note, we won’t be able to even sell the deficit bond if we get it until September of 2013 after our books close for 2012 and the state comptroller certifies exactly what our deficit is,” Legislator Ilan Schoenberger said. 
“The bond is not to exceed $80 million, but the state comptroller must certify the amount. To say that we already put a cap on this when it’s just being initiated and next year will be the first full year that we will be able to achieve the revenue from this and then measure how much that revenue is, and to put a two-year cap on it so that we won’t even have a second year to evaluate it while we’re going to have a 10-year deficit bond, I just don’t think that’s good government.”

The legislators passed a number of other resolutions at Tuesday’s meeting. Here are some of them:

  • While the legislature wanted to ask the state for a 20-year deficit bond, the state representatives instead went with a 10-year bond. To work with the new proposed bond, Legislator Aron Wieder proposed that the home energy tax expire in 10 years to match the bond, as it’s being used to help pay off the bond. It was initially scheduled for 20 years to match the legislature’s proposed bond.
  • The legislature approved giving the sheriff patrol $155,876 in federal forfeiture funds to provide for equipment and software. They also approved $243,650 in federal forfeiture funds for the office of the sheriff for infrastructure upgrades, equipment, K9 care and police training. Another $275,000 in federal forfeiture went to the sheriff for jail infrastructure updates, equipment and training. The district attorney and sheriff received $9,000 in federal forfeiture funds to purchase Smart Board equipment and supplies for the sheriff’s R.E.A.C.T. Unit, which provides services on cases throughout the county.
  • The legislature approved purchases in an excess of $100,000 from Universal Electric Motor Service, Inc. for pumps inspection, overhaul, rewind and repair services. The amount is to not exceed $135,000.
AH June 22, 2012 at 05:44 PM
maybe we should add tax to taffic tickets too! Rockland County is so corrupt. At least one of them had a brain to make it only temporary for two years and this idea shows compromise and leadership.
Tony T June 22, 2012 at 06:55 PM
How can one county charge more to register a car in the same State....how is this constitutional???
Mike Hirsch June 22, 2012 at 08:18 PM
Ed Day has it right. If these are really only temporary taxes to deal with our "temporary" deficits, then these new taxes should have the same shelf life as the deficit. From the actions of the majority of the legislators, I can only conclude that the deficits are as permanent as the new taxes and fees.
Mike June 22, 2012 at 08:36 PM
I think a more appropriate amendment would be that since the Legislature cannot be trusted with fiscal responsibility, any new tax legislation should compel them to provide public accountablity that the said new tax is used solely and exclusively for retiring the debt. In fact, the Legislature should pass a law stating that if by some miracle we have not used budgeted funds in one area, that under law this must either be returned to the tax payers or it must be used exclusively to pay down the debt. Remember, these are fiscal incompetents in New City who simply cannot be trusted with our money- so the only way to protect our hard earned tax dollars is hand-cuff them as much as possible.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »